|
文章编号:1672-3104(2016)03-0061-09 |
|
论医疗过失的判断标准——解读《侵权责任法》第57条对医疗上注意义务的规定 |
|
于佳佳 |
|
(上海交通大学凯原法学院,上海,200030) |
|
摘 要: 我国的《侵权责任法》第57条将医疗上的注意义务定义为“与当时的医疗水平相应的诊疗义务”。“当时”的医疗水平说明,随着医学技术的进步,医疗水平不是静止不变的,与此相应,医疗上的注意义务中包括执业后继续学习的义务。“医疗水平”受医疗的地域差距和医疗的专业性影响。“符合”医疗水平的诊疗并不必然是遵从常规的诊疗,法律要求行医者是合理慎重的医生,依据个案中的具体危险,比较衡量诊疗行为的危险性和治疗效果,采取避免结果发生的恰当诊疗措施。 |
|
关键词: 医疗过失;注意义务;医疗水平;医疗常规;比较衡量 |
|
|
|
On the judgement standard in medical negligence: Interpreting Article 57 of the Tort Law about the doctors’ duty of care in accordance |
|
YU Jiajia |
|
(Ko Guan Law School, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200030, China) |
|
Abstract: According to Article 57 of the Tort Law of China, a doctor owes the duty of performing medical treatment which should meet the current medical standards. The “current ” standards mean that with the development of medical technique, the standards are not still, and therefore, a doctor should continue studying new knowledge and mastering new skills. “The standards” may be defined in different ways because of the differences in access to medical resources and as well the differences in doctors’ specialties. “Meeting” the standards does not necessarily mean following customary medical practice. A doctor should deliberately balance risks and benefits of the measures in issue and take alternative and proper measures in a specific case to avoid medical accidents. |
|
Key words: medical negligence; duty of care; medical standards; customary practice; balancing risks and benefits |
|
|